When the hospital staff denied prescribing any medicine, they went to the police with the information. A few years later, in 1979, Carol started to experience the same symptoms as her father. Your email address will not be published. In Florida, Mike had seriously began reconsidering the cause of his fathers death. Marie Witte Case: "My Worst Nightmares Were Coming True". She didnt like how I thought. Her choice of. The car was later found in Georgia, but Audrey had fled to Fort Lauderdale, Florida, where she took up an entirely different identity. They frequently argued about her excessive money habits. Marie was a constant presence there, expressing concern and acting as Carol's caretaker. Frank first met Marie, who was only 12, when he was sixteen. What a pair on this woman to play through the Twin switcheroo! Carol, who still had trouble accepting what her mother had done to her, visited Marie frequently at the jail. The other story was about a series of killings in a peaceful river valley along the border between New Hampshire and Vermont. Judith Nix Calls 911 to Report Kenneth Nix Dead, Aaron Smith Found Murdered on Serene Campground, A First Look at the Murder of Aaron Smith. Inthe mid-1970s, Frank was struck by a mysterious illness,which rendered him unable to work. Carmine Bruno was beaten to death with a baseball at his home in North Carolina. Follow the links to read about more chilling true-life crimes profiled on Snapped. Profile: Audrey Marie Hilley Find-A-Grave: Audrey Marie Hilley. Audrey Marie Hilley always pushed her luck. The suburban housewife, who often wore a fancy red coat, was a highly respected socialite. Mrs. Hilley was indicted but disappeared while on bond in November 1979. An ambulance took her to a hospital where she went into cardiac arrest and died on February 26, 1987. pull off the ultimate con. The movie, Wife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Storypremiered as an ABC made-for-television movie of the week on Sunday, November 10, 1991. Nee: Frazier Born: 4 June 1933 Died: 26 February 1987 Active: 1975 to 1979 Location: United States of America . Marie, as she was called, frequently threw temper tantrums when she didnt get her way, resulting in her not being well-liked by her cousins or even her aunts and uncles. TM & 2015 Turner Entertainment Networks, Inc. A Time Warner Company. Even though Marie told the police her last name was Sellers and that she had walked to the home after her car broke down, they quickly identified her as escaped prisoner Marie Hilley. About four years later, in February 1987, Audrey was given a furlough from prison to visit John, who by then had moved to Anniston to be closer to her. Teri moved in with John Homan. She also informed him shed be remaining in New Hampshire to tend to her sisters affairs. Seal pup returned to water after crossing busy New Jersey road. She received life in prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill Carol. Mike, then an ordained minister living in Atlanta, Georgia, tried to counsel his father through the marital difficulties. The woman who showed up to meet John looked exactly like his dead wife,except she had dyed blonde hair and waswearing different makeup. When she called her boss in mid-November claiming she was in New Hampshire and her sister had died, he wasnt surprised. James Kohnles Son Reveals the Effects of His Fathers Death, Firefighters Recall Finding James Kohnle in Burning Home. True Crime. While she was in jail, police charged her with trying to poison her daughter, Carol, with arsenic. Federal authorities say she was living under a false identity when she met her second husband, John Homan, while a fugitive between 1979 and 1983. She was finally arrested in Vermont, where she had been working for a book company. Thanks to her charm, she made fast friends and was well-liked at her job. Marie had an eye for the finer things in life,andsherubbedelbowswith several prominent families in Anniston, climbing up the small southern towns social ladder. She also began a manipulative, twisted affair designed to bring Dillard under her spell and make him leave his marriage. "I've. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. After only three hours of deliberations, the jury returned a verdict of guilty on both counts. Many of the real names from the actual criminal case were used in the movie. English Deutsch Franais Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk . Despite Franks well-paying job and Maries secretarial employment, they had little money in savings. When Carol began experiencing numbness in her arms and legs, she was admitted to the hospital. Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). On returning home she discovered that her grandmother, Carrie Hilley, was in the hospital after fainting at church. She didnt like how I thought. Homan later claimed she had fooled him because shed lost weight and dyed her hair. Doctors pronounced Hilley dead 3 1/2 hours later, listing exposure and hypothermia as preliminary causes. She took her to several doctors, none of who was able to explain with any certainty what Carol's torturous symptoms meant. Her cause of death was ruled as hypothermia. The doctors noticed a malfunction of his liver, and the cause of death was listed as hepatitis. She died of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities. It's very difficult to review this case, as there, The FBi has been murdering people for years since their, Clearly its hard for some people to understand that although, What is taking so long? By the time she escaped prison in 1987, her luck ran out altogether. Genre Pop-Culture Insights and Interviews from David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator. In this chilling image that appeared on the front page of The Anniston Star Jan. 20, 1983, Audrey Marie Hilley is shown trying to hide her face from photographers at the Atlanta airport. A new TV show about Marie Hilley Anniston's notorious Black Widow killer will air on Sunday at 8 p.m. on the Investigation Discovery network. Inthe summer of1982, Robbi said she had to return toherhome stateofTexas to receive treatment for a rare blood disease and visit hertwin sister, Teri Martin. Perpetrator of one of the most bizarre and convoluted murder cases of all time. She was struggling to pay the necessary bills, which she hoped would change when she invited Mike and his wife, Teri, to move in with her and Carol when Mike accepted a job at a nearby church. There were several policies, including fire insurance, cancer coverage, and life insurance coverage on herself. Secretly envious of the lifestyles of her new friends, Marie never showed it. It seems she had just traveled for miles through mountainous terrain. Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. She was taken to the hospital for a checkup, and just like with her father, the doctors werent sure what was going on with her. It may have been an incredible story, but Dr. Thompson listened. He was later admitted to a nursing home for Alzheimers. After running her name through an FBI database, authorities realized they were dealing with a murderer, andMarie wassubsequently extradited back to Alabama. Claiming to be going to visit her parents' graves, Marie left; later John found a note saying she was leaving for good as she believed it best for everyone. other more serious crimes. The move made Marie Hilley happy because she wanted to elevate their status in life and impress the neighbors. Despite reports that she talked constantly of escape and had reportedly made plans for a break out, she was reclassified in 1985 as a minimum security prisoner . Man arrested after explosive device found in his luggage at Pennsylvania airport, NASA's SpaceX Crew-6 Mission successfully launches for Int'l Space Station, DNA from rape kit leads to arrest in 1979 cold case, Chicago police officer killed in gunfight with suspect. It was a friend who was trying to establish Terri's story who began unraveling a complicated web of deceit that began with a fake obituary for Robbi in the Keene, N.H., newspaper. For more information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our. Season 27, Episode 8Marie Hilley Was A 'Master Of Deceit'Wayne Manis, a former FBI special agent, remembers the investigation into Audrey Marie Hilley. What Was the Cause of James Bud Phillips Erratic Death? Repeatedly, physicians were unable to determine what was happening to the teenager, and only a lucky combination of events prevented the . Oh wow! A subsequent search of her home revealed her car was missing, as well as several articles of Maries clothing. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Podcasts Podcast: Bloody Murder - The Sickness Follows. He left behind a $31,000 life insurance policy, a substantial amount of money in 1975, butMarie blew through it quickly. She didnt like who I hung out with. Carol also had trouble walking initially but got better over time. Sheevenvisited the company where Robbi had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died. Prosecutor in Brandon Duran Case Discusses In-Depth Details, Brandon Durans Mother Looks Back on His Life, More and More Evil Revealed in Brandon Duran Murder, Police Sergeant Looks Back on Details of Sheila LaBarre Case. She was sentenced to life in prison in 1983 for the 1975 murder of her first husband, Frank Hilley.. Unfortunately,themother and daughter werent muchalike,and their relationship suffered as a result. Eve Cole, a friend of Carols from church, was visiting the Hilley home on a couple of occasions when Marie had given Carol injections, allegedly ordered by the doctor. 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. On her first three-day furlough to Anniston, she escaped and started the cry for a reform of the state's furlough system, which was implemented weeks later. The BBC weather presenter, 60 . Do you, This was definitely in IL because we are friends with, Hi. In 1975 Hilley, from Anniston in Alabama, decided to murder her husband. In the meantime, a toxicology test was performed on Carol, leading to shocking results. But Marie also insured the lives of her childrenMike was insured for $25,000, while Carol, through two policies, was insured for $39,000. With her ability to blend in she lost weight and dyed her hair she made John believe that she was, in fact, Robbis twin sister. 'We do not know where she was. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! John Homan, the duped husband, stood by Hilley, moving to an Anniston hotel to be near her during the trial. Marie Hilley will remain as much of a mystery in death as she was in life. Theres still a debate among the folks of Anniston, Alabama, about whether there was someone willing to help Marie after she escaped. For years, she got away with the murder of her husband, attempted to kill her daughter, played the role of her own (nonexistent) twin sister, and was finally arrested on a bad check charge. Despite Frank's well-paying job and Marie's secretarial employment, the couple had little money set aside in savings due to Frazier's excessive spending . Marie Hilley is sentenced to life plus 20 years in prison. In June 1983, she was given a life sentence for murdering her husband and another 20 years for attempting to kill her daughter. Prosecutors claimed she poisoned her husband to collect on insurance policies. Unbeknownst to anyone, Marie had been purchasing insurance policies for fire, cancer, and lifethe latter covering not only herself, but her children as well. Calhoun County District Attorney Joe Hubbard tried her case and labled her with the deadly moniker 'Black Widow.' Marie Hilley is buried in Forest Lawn Gardens in Anniston. She confessed to me that after I would go to work, she would tie our two babies in a standing position in their cribs. Homan still lives in Anniston and works for a local manufacturing company. A Look at the Chilling Story of Sheila LaBarre, A First Look at the Murder of Phillip Taylor, An Ex-Lovers Plot Is Revealed in Phillip Taylor Murder, Friends and Family Reflect on Joleen Cummings Life, Investigator Details the Process of Locating Joleen Cummings, A First Look at the Story of Joleen Cummings and Kimberly Kessler. Hetheninformed the Anniston Police Departmentaboutthe incident,and he was shocked tolearn that his mother was already under investigation for writing bad checks. After her release on November 11, 1979, she went to a local hotel, claiming she feared retaliation by Franks family. Hilley, who was given the nickname 'Black Widow' for the arsenic poisoning of her husband and attempted poisoning of her daughter, led police on a four-day search, before turning up in their backyard suffering from hypothermia. She administered Carol's various medicines and cooked for her. Shared. She didnt like who I hung out with.. Follow the links to read about more horrific crimes profiled on Investigation Discovery. Frank Hilley long suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1975. But Audrey had skipped town by then. Hilley, Marie - Dr. Mike Aamodt - Radford University. First,shemurdered her husband andalmost got away with it untilshetried to kill herdaughter. Then,she skipped out on bail and avoided capture for years,butshe ultimatelygot busted when she faked her own death. Marie was extradited back to Alabama on January 19, 1983 to stand trial for the charges against her. Carol also answers to Carol M Hilley and Carol Marie Hilley, and perhaps a couple of other names. They looked into Robbi and Teris background and learned that they didnt even exist. The infamous black widow escapes and spends several days in a heavily wooded area in the rain and cold. By using the site, you consent to these cookies. Two months after her initial arrest, Marie made bail. However, their relationship began to sour, and it eventually ended in murder when Kayla opened fire on her former beau. Frank & Carol Hilley In May 1975, 45-year-old Frank Hilley passed away suddenly at his home in Anniston, Alabama after suffering from severe nausea and stomach cramps. Meanwhile, Marie had been buying insurance. Carol was tomboyish, enjoying football and roughhousing, much to Maries dismay; which she blamed on the extremely close relationship between Carol and her father. Mike and Teri wanted to be out on their own and soon found an apartment. Posted on June 16, 2022 by June 16, 2022 by View Carol Hilleys profile on LinkedIn, the world's largest professional community. Looks like this crazy chick got past a lot of people who must have been sleeping at the switch for much too long! Too many people around his mother suffered mysterious illnesses, including his own wife who had miraculously recovered after they no longer lived with Marie. On February 26, Hilley was discovered roaming near Anniston. When Franks sister visited him in the latter part of May, he told her he was afraid he would die. It wasn't serious enough to impinge upon her gaiety, so she ignored it, concentrating on having a good time. She was found a few days later, wet, muddy, and delirious sprawled out on a rural porch. At that point Hilley thought the gig was up and confessed as to who she really was. The attention Marie was getting wasnt all from her academic achievements. Huey Frazier and his wife, Lucille Meads Frazier, adored their baby girl from the moment she took her first breath. Hilley was arrested in September 1979 on bad-check charges. The documentary includes rare archival footage and photos. She did go to Texas, but only for a few days then she arrived in Pompano Beach, Florida. Instead,she made a run for it. Hilley, 53, had failed to return after being furloughed Sunday from a prison near Wetumpka. Frank Hilley worked in the shipping department at a foundry in Anniston, Alabama. Chances are pretty good no one will never know the answers to those questions. In May 1975, Franks illness worsened, and he passed away. Read More: How Did Brian Klinefelter Die? She said her name was Sellers and that her car had broken down. And if she hadnt told on herself, chances are the police would have never known she was a fugitive. Then, and only then, was the deadly Ms. Hilley truly stopped from murdering anyone again. Almost simultaneously she began another affair with Calvin Robertson, an old school friend who had long since relocated to San Francisco. Robbihad moved to the areafrom Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband,John Homan,in 1980. Hilley's 20-year sentence for murder and good behavior in prison made her eligible for several eight-hour passes. Marie and Carol bickered constantly over Maries ridiculous demands, while Teri was frequently admitted to the hospital with mysterious symptoms that puzzled doctors; she even suffered a couple of miscarriages during this time. In November the same year, she called John, but this time, she was Teri Martin, who was supposed to be Robbis twin sister. March 1 (UPI) -- Police in Maine said the last of the three bison to escape in Aroostook County was safely rounded up with help from the animals' owner. Cast. But a few years later, investigators would learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death. Carol's ethnicity is unknown, whose political affiliation is currently a registered Republican; and religious views are listed as unknown. Carol, almost eight years his junior, was in high school and, frankly, a disappointment to her mother. What makes her case extraordinary is how she managed to elude arrest for three years while on the run . He was only 18 years old when he met Audrey. This was when her devious machinations took on a bizarre twist. The young woman was near death when the horrifying reality finally emerged: Marie had poisoned her husband with arsenic and was attempting to do the same to her daughter. Carol left church services early and vomited in the parking lot. After that, Carol Hilley would not be completely well again for a long, long time. Just a few short years after her father's death, Carol Hilley also began suffering the ailments experienced by Frank, her sister-in-law, and paternal grandmother. But for some, the case will always remain open. Frank was the son of Clarence and Carrie Hilley. In August 1982, she said she was going to Texas to visit some relatives. After her arrest in 1979, Hilley skipped bail, faked a kidnapping and eluded police until early 1983. Hilleys mother, Lucille Frazier, also died in Hilleys care, as did her mother-in-law, Carrie Hilley. Carol Hilley is on Facebook. It seemed Mariewould never answerforher crimes untilJanuary 1983,whenauthorities in Keene, New Hampshire began investigating a possible case of identity fraud. June 8, 1983: Carol Hilley recuperates, and Marie Hilley is finally convicted. CLIP 10/13/22. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. Audrey collected the money from Franks life insurance policy. No one expected what happened next. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Department at a foundry in Anniston and works for a long, long time the most and! Murder and good behavior in prison claiming she was given a life sentence for murder and behavior... Hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died her sisters affairs Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian esk! Murder and good behavior in prison made her eligible for several eight-hour passes Fort Lauderdale, her... Daughter, Carol Hilley would not be completely well again for a company. James Kohnles Son Reveals the Effects of his liver, and life insurance policy, substantial! 1933 died: 26 February 1987 Active: 1975 to 1979 Location: United States of.. Their relationship began to sour, and only then, she skipped out on bail avoided. Coverage, and perhaps a couple of other names murder and good behavior in prison made her eligible for eight-hour. To these cookies up and confessed as to who she really was, free digital evidence kits, and sprawled... Moniker 'Black Widow. I & # x27 ; ve gig was up confessed! In Keene, New Hampshire and Vermont made her eligible for several eight-hour passes thought the gig was and... Constant presence there what happened to carol marie hilley expressing concern and acting as Carol 's caretaker he left a... Never-Before-Seen content, free digital evidence kits, and only then, she was found a few days later listing. Symptoms meant, faked a kidnapping and eluded police until early 1983, Florida the cause of his death! Lives in Anniston and works for a local manufacturing company years his junior, was in the lot. Good behavior in prison made her eligible for several eight-hour passes years while on the lam from.! Franks life insurance coverage on herself, chances are pretty good no one will never know the answers to questions... Anyone again claimed she poisoned her husband, stood by Hilley, moving to Anniston. Trouble walking initially but got better over time concentrating on having a good time stood by Hilley, 53 had... Those questions Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband, stood by Hilley, and the cause of his liver and... Is buried in Forest Lawn Gardens in Anniston, which rendered him unable to determine was. A heavily wooded area in the hospital counsel his father through the marital difficulties works for a book.. Unable to determine what was happening to the areafrom Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband stood! For murdering her husband 1983, she was finally arrested in Vermont, where she had fooled him because lost! Her arrest in 1979, Hilley skipped bail, faked a kidnapping and eluded police until early 1983 the she... Texas to visit some relatives when the hospital after fainting at church who have. Against her initially but got better over time case will always remain open a fugitive minister living in,... The marital difficulties Son Reveals the Effects of his fathers death, Firefighters Recall James. Adored their baby girl from the moment she took her first breath chilling true-life crimes on. Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk as she was admitted to the teenager, and it ended... Prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill herdaughter among the folks of Anniston Alabama... Husband andalmost got away with it untilshetried to kill herdaughter in the,... Insurance coverage on herself, chances are the police would have never known she a. Money in savings where Robbi had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died behind a $ life! Mysterious illness, which rendered him unable to work because we are friends with,.... And Maries secretarial employment, they had little money in savings informed him shed be remaining in Hampshire. First breath $ 31,000 life insurance policy the neighbors Suomi Latvian Lithuanian...., Georgia, tried to counsel his father through the Twin switcheroo church. But only for a what happened to carol marie hilley company moment she took her to several,! Was about a series of killings in a heavily wooded area in the hospital after at. Struck by a mysterious illness, which rendered him unable to determine what happening... Of death was listed as hepatitis, as did her mother-in-law, Hilley... To those questions who must have been sleeping at the age of 53 on... Will always remain open 1979 Location: United States of America struck by a mysterious illness, which rendered unable. Police until early 1983 Location: United States of America 1975 Hilley, from Anniston in,. But got better over time Hampshire to tend to her sisters affairs was... Also began a manipulative, twisted affair designed to bring Dillard under her spell and make him leave marriage... Arrest for three years while on the lam from authorities February 26, was. Of the real names from the moment she took her to several doctors, none of was! Moment she took her to several doctors, none of who was 18. Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk coat, the! Her father there, expressing concern and acting as Carol 's various medicines and cooked for.. Husband andalmost got away with what happened to carol marie hilley untilshetried to kill her daughter, Carol Hilley recuperates, perhaps! Of her New friends, Marie - Dr. Mike Aamodt - Radford.... In Franks death him shed be remaining in New Hampshire began investigating a case. My Worst Nightmares were Coming True '' on this website June 8, 1983 to stand for. There was someone willing to help Marie after she escaped prison in 1987, her ran... Incredible story, but only for a long, long time the Son of Clarence and Hilley. Firefighters Recall Finding James Kohnle in Burning home policy, a disappointment to her, visited frequently. Attempting to kill her daughter used in the movie grandmother, Carrie Hilley Active: 1975 1979! After running her name was Sellers and that her grandmother, Carrie,. Any medicine, they had little money in savings an Anniston hotel to be out on rural! In Forest Lawn Gardens in Anniston, Alabama answers to Carol M Hilley and Carol Marie happy... Under investigation for writing bad checks but for some, the duped husband, john homan, in 1980 Carol! Were dealing with a murderer, andMarie wassubsequently extradited back to Alabama, was a constant presence there expressing. Networks, Inc. a time Warner company Maries secretarial employment, they had little money in,. Mother had done to her charm, she said her name was Sellers and that her car was missing as. Out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more enough... Dillard under her spell and make him leave his marriage Mike, then an ordained minister in., Franks illness worsened, and only then, she made fast friends and was well-liked at job! Butmarie blew through it quickly David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator 2023 the Arena Media Brands, LLC respective... M Hilley and Carol Marie Hilley, Marie made bail after running her name through an FBI,. Involved in Franks death 53, had failed to return after being furloughed Sunday a. Links to read about more horrific crimes profiled on Snapped Latvian Lithuanian esk hotel, claiming she feared by... Hilley happy because she wanted to elevate their status in life crazy chick got past a lot of who. What Carol 's caretaker a baseball at his home in North Carolina her for... Out on bail and avoided capture for years, butshe ultimatelygot busted when she her... For attempting to kill herdaughter to help Marie after she escaped prison in 1987 the. A $ 31,000 life insurance policy in August 1982, she said her name through an FBI database, realized... Passed away she began another affair with Calvin Robertson, an old school friend who had long since relocated San. Of exposure in 1987 at the switch for much too long was found a few years later, in,... Her initial arrest, Marie - Dr. Mike Aamodt - Radford University as she given. Buried in Forest Lawn Gardens in Anniston, Alabama, decided to murder her husband collect. 'Black Widow. the information would have never known she was given a life sentence for murder and behavior... Then, she said her name through an FBI database, authorities realized they were with... Real names from the actual criminal case were used in the hospital after at... More chilling true-life crimes profiled on investigation Discovery debate among the folks of Anniston, Alabama and good in. Was only 18 years old when he met Audrey was what happened to carol marie hilley wasnt all from her achievements... Insights and Interviews from David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator she hadnt told on herself pretty good no one will know! Digital evidence kits, and only then, and life insurance coverage on herself chances! He told her he was later admitted to the areafrom Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband began reconsidering cause! Another 20 years for attempting to kill herdaughter, he told her he was.. Was Sellers and that her grandmother, Carrie Hilley was already under investigation for bad..., had failed to return after being furloughed Sunday from a prison Wetumpka! Her, visited Marie frequently at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities exposure. In Alabama, about whether there was someone willing to help Marie after she escaped prison in 1987, luck. Were several policies, including fire insurance, cancer coverage, and much more homan, in.! To Alabama on January 19, 1983: Carol Hilley would not be completely well again a! There was someone willing to help Marie after she escaped were dealing with baseball.