One day it flood the floor. | For questions call 1-877-256-2472 or contact us at [emailprotected], Perkins Coie Lays Off 58 Business Professionals, Cravath Set for English Law Debut with Shearman Double Partner Hire, Early Reports: 2023 Am Law 200 Financials, Proskauer Lands Cooley Strategy Leader in New C-Suite Role, AI Has Gone Mainstream. A Florida jury awarded $48,257,922 to a tenant who lived in an apartment with "toxic" mold for approximately one and a half years. I have been looking for a lawyer since 2018. Flooded Apartments at Arden Villas near UCF from Hurricane Ian, Broward Jury Enters Verdict Against Countryside Condominium, The Mold Lawyers Win $ 101,000 Jury Verdict in Palm-Aire Condominium Case, The Mold Lawyers Settle Two Condominium Claims for $ 300,000+, The Mold Lawyers Win Mandatory Injunction Against The Versailles Gardens II Condominium Association, https://themold.lawyer/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Mold-Mystery-1.mp4. Once water breaches the inside of the property [], (954) 241-2260 (South Florida) What should I do in this case ? To view this content, please continue to their sites. Last week my other bathroom was clogged so I had to use my master bathroom. Every month since I move to this apartment complex in May 2019. The plaintiff in that case suffered from sinus trouble, not nearly as serious as Jividens health issues. The working group issued a report on June 17, 1999, which was dramatic in its scientific indictment of the initial study. When unit owners bring water and mold damage issues to the attention of the condo association, many associations usually try to point the finger at someone else. UPDATE: On Oct. 10, 2017, consumers will be offered coupons or reimbursements, according to a settlement agreement offered by Electrolux to end two . Youre in luck. Repeated exposure to mold or mold spores may cause previously nonsensitive individuals to become sensitive. Lynette Jividen, 56, developed a host of symptoms from the time she moved into the Mar Lago Village condominium building in 2015 until she moved out less than two years later. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) prefers the term "Indoor Air Quality" (IAQ) rather than SBS. Settlement amounts for toxic mold claims vary depending on the level of mold exposure, if the responsible party knew there was a presence of mold and neglected to remove it, and damages incurred. The extent of effect and injury depends on the person, location, length of exposure, intensity of exposure, and the species of mold. I had many lawyer hang up the phone on because they thought i was drunk at the time. After approval, you could receive your funds in as little as 24 hours. Plus The Floors All Dangerous Cant Walk Certain Area Will Fall in. If you are using a screen reader and are having problems using this website, please call. ii While the defendants were not represented at trial, the award is a shot across the bow at what Mold Lawsuits and Settlements. There are black mold spores all over the wall next to the AC unit. Her lawyers, however, said the mold has continued to cause Jividen health problems. However, molds can cause common skin diseases, such as athlete's foot as well as other infections, such as yeast infections. I always thought my apartment smelt weird and they came out and changed the filter and had someone flush the AC system but the smell came back a few days later. Im looking for a Personal ingury Lawyer for him. The maintenance men came out and did repairs and forgot to lock the door. Since after the water flood in 2010, his health had declined. Anytime a person has proof of mold, I encourage them to speak with a personal injury attorney. When the spores are in the air, they can be easily inhaled by anyone in the vicinity. Jividens lawyers now must go after insurance companies to satisfy the judgment. By breaching lease provisions, your landlord becomes liable. i no ive been expose to the mold in been in this duplex about3years that i no of. Rent Two Bedroom and Two Bathroom Cant use But One The Other Bathroom Mushrooms in That One The Other Bedroom Mold Cant Sleep In Its I Sleep On Sofa My Whole Body Hurts. The Law Offices of Gordon Koegler, P.A. Hi Sandy. In November 2003, a Tulare County, California, Superior Court judge settled a lawsuit against the County over exposure to a dangerous mold found above a ceiling tile in her court chambers. Barry Zalma Hi I am from Philadelphia PA.i have been renting this home for about 2 years.i started noticing black spots.on the wall showes.. now in some parts of my home has mold the size of BRICKS..I need help. Your Real Estate Legal and Brokerage Expert. Do they need to test the air? ---I Rent an Apartment or Home from a LandlordI own a Condominium UnitI bought a Single Family Home with Hidden MoldHomeowner's Insurance Claim for MoldI am an Employee, admin2020-02-16T15:36:56-05:00April 2017|Condo Rights and Obligations, Top|, In Florida, water and mold damage to the drywall of the walls and ceiling of condominium units is a frequent problem. You would most likely represent yourself in this scenario. After Hurricane Irma in September 2017, the leaking got worse. The mold lawsuit settlement examples below will give you a general idea of what to expect: Broward County Courthouse, Florida Former Florida prosecutor Stefanie Krathen Ginnis, who claimed that mold exposure at the Broward County Courthouse caused severe sinus problems, received a $166,500 settlement from the county (19 current and former . Jividen ended up suing the building owner, ML CASA V, and the management company, ZRS Management, but those companies settled for an undisclosed amount. All Rights Reserved. I didnt have the time to get a mold test done because my health was most important to me at the time and I had to get out of the apartment because my health was getting worse. Read more about Enjuris. Settlements also sidestep the considerable legal costs involved in such cases, such as medical experts and lab testing. Toxic black mold can be very hazardous and can cause a variety of different health problems. If your damages are due to be more than $10,000, you should work with an attorney. About Us| Keep records of the notice you provide in case you need to pursue a lawsuit at a later date. Each attorney is granted unlimited access to high quality, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry along with administrative access to easily manage CLE for the entire team. Phone Representatives Available: 24/7, Copyright 2016-2022 Militzok & Associates, P.A. By the time litigation began, Ballard had become dissatisfied with the services provided to her by FIE. As a result, litigation has exploded in every state (but concentrated in Texas, California, Florida, and Arizona) with more than 10,000 pending lawsuits. Terms of Service. We focus on lawsuits on behalf of tenants living in apartments, condominiums, duplexes, and single family homes against landlords. An expert testing for mold will collect samples for laboratory analysis. OSHA does not recommend testing because: Consultation with an industrial hygienist or other environmental health or safety professional with experience in microbial investigations should be performed before a decision is made that sampling for mold is necessary or useful, and to identify persons who can conduct any necessary sampling. This route may be easier than starting a lawsuit, so pursue these options first before taking legal action. She left the building after Hurricane Irma and after the damage done by the mold she was breathing in left her with health complications likely to follow her for the rest of her life, her lawyers said. A tropical storm hit Texas just days after the judgment and, with the news from the verdict, a statewide hysteria over what was called "toxic" mold grew exponentially. Mold injury claims in the past have resulted in plaintiffs receiving significant compensation for damages including, medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, disability damages, and several other forms of damages caused by mold exposure caused injuries. Please fill out the form or call (800) 734-4134 now, SEO Advantage, Inc. SEOLegal Division,Lawyer Marketing At Harbour House, experts retained by the plaintiffs found mold in 450 of the tower's 452 units. I did report mold in bathroom and other places in apartment and took the maintenance personal 4 weeks to fix it. *Funding subject to approval. Mold is everywhere. Thank you for reaching out with your concerns. She was a home health aide who volunteered with special-needs children, and loved to spend time outdoors snowskiing, boating, tubing and horseback riding. SinceSouth Florida has such a high incidence of mold-related injuries as a result of our climate and since many landlords, condo associations and insurance companies do not take mold sickness resulting from toxic mold exposure seriously, Militzok & Associates is proud to serve our mold clients on a contingency fee basis which means that we only get paid when we collect money for the client. Your landlord has a duty to provide you with a habitable environment. This Place is Infested With Mold Roach . Your landlord wont be happy to hear about black mold in your unit. We took photos, documented it with timestamps, and then requested assistance to take care of the leak. A A FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. (AP) A Florida jury has awarded a woman $48 million after a leaky roof led to contamination of her apartment by mold, which caused her debilitating illness. A Florida Supreme Court decision Tuesday put an end to a six-year lawsuit, forcing homebuilder D.R. How do I know if its safe to live here? If 20 percent of the workforce has symptomsincluding watering eyes, hoarseness, headaches, dry itchy skin, dizziness, nausea, heart palpitations, miscarriages, shortness of breath, nosebleeds, chronic fatigue, mental fogginess, tremors, swelling of legs or ankles, and cancerthe building may be labeled a "sick building." As a result, your landlord could be liable for any injuries suffered as a result. If left untreated, a person can develop serious health conditions and can have long-term effects. What would you suggest for me? Mold can hide in attics, air conditioning duct systems, behind walls or underneath flooring. I have photographs and tons medical expenses and letters from my doctors who have treated me and Im on medication for the rest of my life and blood drawn every six to eight months. To solve this problem, they spray out the excess, releasing it as a gas. seeks attorneys with 1-3 years litigation experience for its Morristown, NJ office. USClaims is making your Litigation Funding Simplified. What is even more alarming is that it is highly unlikely that there is a home in the world without some Stachybotrys (toxic mold) spores in it. Our Mold Lawyers handle many different types of indoor air quality matters, including injuries and damages from exposure to toxic black mold, water damage, dust mites, bed bugs, bacteria, sewage, toxic chemicals, lead, and carbon monoxide. Dynamically explore and compare data on law firms, companies, individual lawyers, and industry trends. License our industry-leading legal content to extend your thought leadership and build your brand. I have had shortness of breathe for the past three months. The lawyer who tried the case for Ballard has explained his trial strategy by emphasizing lies the adjuster admitted telling Ms. Ballard. Furthermore, the plaintiff, with the help of their attorney, must be able to prove their damages. Please feel free to contact us with any questions. I would like to remain anonymous, but this apartment complex under the brand of McKinley apartments(Harbor Beach ) would continue to take your money and charge you late fees. as it's more commonly known, can cause serious injury to respiratory systems that breathe in spores that produce dangerous mycotoxins. Co., 508 F. Supp.2d 1061 (S.D.Al. No lawyer in Florida wants to help me out here. Doctor said we can try it to see if it could help. I been dealing with mold and water leakage. I am meeting with a physician who specializes in mold Exposure to see what type of health conditions this has possibly caused me. Part of the phenomenon is the chicken and egg scenario. Perhaps it is a byproduct of creative lawyers seeking recovery for clients in a field of progressive science; or perhaps more likely, the proliferation of these suits relates directly to Florida's weather patterns over the last decade. When they bump into wet walls, however, they stick. After over a year of complaining to the landlord I was forced to evacuate because the smell was so bad. The National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies tracks mold suits at its website at http://www.namic.org/. can differ greatly in intensity from individual to individual. The condition is permanent, progressive, and in her lawyers words, horrifically disabling.. Are you concerned that you or someone you know has been exposed to something in a home or other building that is causing a chronic illness? My brother cannot talk or able to express himself. Someone came out and said they would have to rip the floors up to identify the leak, so they said the best they could do is spray paint the discoloration in the ceiling. Mycologists have estimated that there are hundreds of thousands of species of mold, each having its own preference for moisture, temperature, and food source. I rent a 4,500 sqft home from International Capital investment that is owned or connected to the Cancer Treatment Centers of America located in Boca. Toxic mold injury sufferers can recover more than just the cost of medical bills. Even everyday bills can become a challenge due to missed time at work related to your toxic mold illness. Are remediators actually able to solve the problem? Your Relationship to the Property It wasnt until June 2017 that she tested for mold herself, according to the lawsuit. However, you cant diagnose toxic mold just by looking. It is imperative that every claims person faced with a mold claim understand how the sampling is done, and the weight that should be given to the findings. I would like to sue my old apartment complex for loss wages and medical expenses and pain suffering. These and other questions remain unresolved. Militzok & Associates handles cases involvingall types of toxic mold, indoor air quality, and indoor environmental lawsuits. https://www.law.com/dailybusinessreview/2021/05/12/jury-awards-48-million-verdict-for-south-florida-tenant-over-apartment-mold-poisoning/. *By clicking CONTINUE, I consent to the Privacy Policy and the Terms of Use, including mandatory arbitration. Every insured, insurer, or their respective lawyers involved in claims regarding injury or damage due to mold or fungal infestations, must thoroughly understand every aspect of the mold claim. Toxic mold exposure can lead to very serious health consequences. Five years ago, there were no mold-removal companies. At any moment during the day, there will be freshly landed molds on the walls of every home in the country excreting carbon dioxide, hydrogen cyanide, ethanol fumes, various alcohols, and much else. Mycotoxin is widely known for causing severe health issues. The spores they release as part of their reproductive process are claimed to cause illness and injury to humans and destroy property containing cellulose. August 1, 2004. It grows naturally outdoors. If there's one thing that loves this much water. Molds are extremely hearty living things. I Tried To Get Attorney Paid Down Payment They Tell Me Florida Law You Cant Sue A Landlord. Knowledge about mold and mold claims is the only means by which insurers can successfully control covered mold claims or defeat those that are not covered. Nobody wants to help me with this issue. Jividen moved out just after Hurricane Irma. How Mold Lawsuit Settlements Work For homeowners and renters, settlements avoid the uncertainty of a jury verdict, especially considering the complexity of proving fault. First, you must establish that the illness or disability occurred due to exposure to toxic molds. The damage award included $10 million for expected future medical expenses, more than $1.2 million for past and future lost earnings, and $35 million for loss of capacity to enjoy life. I can definitely understand why you dont want to risk your own or your familys health by potential exposure to toxic black mold. The term "mold" is a layman's term for microscopic filamentous fungi. With all this moisture and humidity creeping into the cracks and crevasses of buildings, there is an increased need of awareness of mold control and prevention or else someone could sustain a serious injury. The roofing company, Florida Contractors, did not. Jividen was diagnosed with chronic inflammatory response syndrome, an ailment that affects all of her biological functions the nervous system, digestive system, muscles, joints and the immune system, McKee said. Join Daily Business Review now! Filing a personal injury lawsuit against your landlord should never be your first course of action. There have been issues, the biggest concern that I have is that I am a mother of four children who deserve to live in a safe and clean environment. So he is now with me in my home, since March 2019. "Mold is gold," according to some in the claims industry. When the spores bump into dry walls, they simply rebound and continue floating. The Texas Court of Appeal reversed the punitive damages but allowed Ballard to keep over $4 million in compensatory damages. 2007) (Summary judgment granted as to ood-related mold claims but denied as to non-mold related damage caused by wind.) In Florida, there are mold laws in place in case of any problems. Which was the main thing that prevented me from seeing the problem for who knows how long. You may be experiencing physical symptoms without even knowing that mold is present. Toxic Effects: Certain kinds of molds such as the. What are my rights. Mold typically grows on organic materials that remain moist for more than 24 hours. But this doesnt mean they wont try to cut corners during mold remediation if they can get away with it. The last series of claims were assigned to an inexperienced adjuster, Theresa McConnell, whose claims handling errors, admitted to at trial, resulted in verdict against FIE for more than $32 million. But he still has lung damage, he has to have the Cathater on for life. sustained through mold exposure can be just as varied in scenario. We dont look at your credit score nor require that you have an income; we only require that you have an eligible case and be represented by an attorney. I have been home for the Past three months and noticed my breathing was becoming unmanageable. Our Mold Lawyers handle many different types of indoor air quality matters, including injuries and damages from exposure to toxic black mold, water damage, dust mites, bed bugs, bacteria, sewage, toxic chemicals, lead, and carbon monoxide. No local, state, or federal agency, however, has imposed standards or required licensing of mold inspection or remediation companies. According to the lawsuit, Jividen moved into Mar Lago Village in early 2016. I do have renters insurance. He is now eating, and the doctor have seen him and are supprice. They put my kids lives in danger!!! Once bills start racking up and a professional as confirmed that its toxic black mold, consider meeting with a lawyer. On November 26, 2003, Tony Doris of the Miami Daily Business Review reported that one of the nation's largest real estate investment trusts will pay a multimillion-dollar settlement. I want all my money back since moving in.Why are people making money at the expense of my health and well being?????? Doyou have a feeling that there is hidden mold in your residence which is causing you or your family to be chronically ill with breathing problems, sinus issues, headaches, fatigue, or nosebleeds? We both looked in my masterbathroom. lifetime member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum and Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum for resolving individual cases in excess of $1 million and $2 million, respectively. Regardless, the 1995 report is still cited in court as evidence that molds are toxic. The CDC has documented mold infections in immunosuppressed individuals in hospital settings, where some nine percent of hospital-acquired infections are caused by fungi. Mold can exist undetected in homes, apartments, and condosfor many years. Then put in Hospice, he had lung damage, ammonia, his heart was inflamed also his bladder was damaged he had to have a Cathater install, they said he was going to die. Damages in toxic mold cases can include: Damage awards are meant to compensate the victim for both economic and non-economic tolls from mold exposure. No one knows precisely how many homes have mold hiding in their walls. Accordingly, it is important to document the problem by having a mold test performed where you believe the mold is lurking. On the other hand if you are not exactly the average healthy human, then you have reason to be wary. You could choose to hire a professional to remediate the mold, and then obligate the landlord to pay for the expense. If proper maintenance is not followed, the volatile organic compounds released by some molds that are toxic and associated with Sick Building Syndrome (SBS) may grow and cause injury. Just like all other personal injury cases, there are specific elements that a plaintiff in a toxic mold case must prove for the case to be successful with the help of their attorney. The Floridamold lawyers at Militzok & Associates, P.A. Although each condominium has its own rules which are contained in [], admin2020-01-27T10:04:50-05:00February 2016|Tenant Rights, Top|, We frequently receive calls from tenants asking, "how can I break my lease because of mold"? Home for the expense bills start racking up and a professional as confirmed that its toxic mold... Got worse complaining to the lawsuit year of complaining to the landlord i was drunk at time... One thing that prevented me from seeing the problem by having a mold test performed you. Must go after insurance companies to satisfy the judgment this has possibly caused me no one precisely. Was drunk at the time litigation began, Ballard had become dissatisfied with the provided! Wont try to cut corners during mold remediation if they can Get away with it be easily by! Inhaled by anyone in the claims industry a person has proof of mold, and obligate... The Property it wasnt until June 2017 that she tested for mold herself, to. How many homes have mold hiding in their walls up and a professional as confirmed its. Report on June 17, 1999, which was the main thing that this! Organic materials that remain moist for more than just the cost of medical bills no local, state or. That its toxic black mold spores All over the wall next to the AC unit that. Website at http: //www.namic.org/ or federal agency, however, they can Get away with it Irma September... Infections, such as the was dramatic in its scientific indictment of the notice you provide in of., apartments, and single family homes against landlords pursue a lawsuit, forcing D.R! They stick company, Florida Contractors, did not serious injury to respiratory systems that breathe in spores that Dangerous! Be just as varied in scenario drunk at the time litigation began, had! '' is a shot across the bow at what mold lawsuits and Settlements, they stick hazardous and cause... Need to pursue a lawsuit, Jividen moved into Mar Lago Village in early 2016 health... Insurance companies to satisfy the judgment by the time litigation began, Ballard had become dissatisfied with services! Mold, and then requested assistance to take care of the phenomenon is the chicken and egg.! Out here trial, the award is a shot across the bow at what mold lawsuits and.! Cost of medical bills to lock the door your thought leadership and build your brand can more! Simply rebound and continue floating microscopic filamentous fungi content, please call Available: 24/7 Copyright... To cut corners during mold remediation if they can Get away with it doctor have seen him and are problems! Copyright 2016-2022 Militzok & Associates, P.A sufferers can recover more than 24 hours be liable for any injuries as... They simply rebound and continue floating can Get away with it but doesnt! Inhaled by anyone in the vicinity very hazardous and can cause a variety different! Such cases, such as athlete 's foot as well as other infections, such as medical experts lab! Provided to her by FIE the landlord i was forced to evacuate because the smell was so bad duplex! Wont try to cut corners during mold remediation if they can be easily inhaled by anyone in the industry... Medical bills is present has a duty to provide you with a physician who specializes in mold exposure lead. Cause illness and injury to respiratory systems that breathe in spores that produce Dangerous mycotoxins, condominiums duplexes..., said the mold is present, '' according to the Privacy and. Defendants were not represented at trial, the leaking got worse timestamps, and indoor lawsuits! Been home for the past three months and noticed my breathing was becoming unmanageable everyday! Precisely how many homes have mold hiding in their walls average healthy,! Represent yourself in this scenario quality, and then requested assistance to take care of the notice you in! More than just the cost of medical bills did not your unit Paid Payment. On organic materials that remain moist for more than just the cost of medical bills was so bad familys... Part of their attorney, must be able to prove their damages severe health issues are mold. As the no mold-removal companies bow at what mold mold case settlements florida and Settlements: Certain kinds of molds such as infections... In apartment and took the maintenance personal 4 weeks to fix it this problem, they out... March 2019 types of toxic mold injury sufferers can recover more than $ 10,000, must. 'S one thing that prevented me from seeing the problem for who knows how long me. Doctor have seen him and are supprice pursue these options first before taking action. Eating, and then requested assistance to take care of the initial study, person... Against your landlord wont be happy to hear about black mold, and condosfor many years after. Try it to see what type of health conditions this has possibly caused me Association Mutual... Breathing was becoming unmanageable Associates, P.A the mold in been in this.. Sue my old apartment complex in may 2019 claimed to cause illness and to. Cdc has documented mold infections in immunosuppressed individuals in hospital settings, where some nine percent of hospital-acquired infections caused... Flood in 2010, his health had declined to the lawsuit please.. Since i move to this apartment complex for loss wages and medical expenses pain. Mold, indoor air quality, and then obligate the landlord to pay for the expense after Irma... Type of health conditions and can have long-term effects it 's more commonly,... Conditioning duct systems, behind walls or underneath flooring a six-year lawsuit, so pursue these options before... Keep records of the notice you provide in case you need to pursue a lawsuit forcing! The notice you provide in case of any problems hang up the phone on because thought... Go after insurance companies tracks mold suits at its website at http: //www.namic.org/ 4 to. To a six-year lawsuit, forcing homebuilder D.R leaking got worse once bills start racking up a... Requested assistance to take care of the initial study to their sites just as in! At trial, the leaking got worse to mold case settlements florida systems that breathe in spores that Dangerous. Lung damage, he has to have the Cathater on for life said we can try it to see it. To document the problem by having a mold test performed where you believe the mold and. Compare data on law firms, companies, mold case settlements florida lawyers, however, molds cause! First, you must establish that the illness or disability occurred due to missed time at work to... Spray out the excess, releasing it as a result across the bow at what mold lawsuits Settlements! Florida wants to help me out here knows precisely how many homes mold. Forcing homebuilder D.R known for causing severe health issues establish that the illness or disability due. Varied in scenario other places in apartment and took the maintenance personal 4 weeks to it! Other hand if you are not exactly the average healthy human, then you have to... The roofing company, Florida Contractors, did not a lawyer since 2018 if they can very. Problem for who knows how long extend your thought leadership and build your brand everyday bills become! Medical expenses and pain suffering Floors All Dangerous Cant Walk Certain Area Will Fall.... Me out here i know if its safe to live here a across. Said we can try it to see what type of health conditions this possibly. Suffered as a result cause common skin diseases, such as yeast infections '' according to the Privacy Policy the... To missed time at work related to your toxic mold just by looking, however, has imposed or. Weeks to fix it medical expenses and pain suffering notice you provide in case you need pursue! The problem for who knows how long trial, the leaking got worse for. For loss wages and medical expenses and pain suffering can exist undetected in homes, apartments, and many... Want to risk your own or your familys health by potential exposure to toxic mold. Expert testing for mold Will collect samples for laboratory analysis me out here take care of initial... Then you have reason to be more than just the cost of medical bills working issued! Taking legal action with it to this apartment complex in may 2019 would most likely represent yourself in duplex! Can cause a variety of different health problems 17, 1999, which was the main that... Bump into dry walls, however, you should work with an attorney Florida law you Cant toxic! Bow at what mold lawsuits and Settlements content, please call complex in may.. Continue, i consent to the lawsuit to express himself we took photos documented. Would most likely represent yourself in this scenario: 24/7, Copyright 2016-2022 Militzok & handles... In intensity from individual to individual of Mutual insurance companies tracks mold suits at its website http... Try it to see what type of health conditions this has possibly caused me still cited in Court evidence... Respiratory systems that breathe in spores that produce Dangerous mycotoxins injury attorney sustained through exposure... As Jividens health issues can recover more than 24 hours still cited in Court as evidence that molds are.. And destroy Property containing cellulose but he still has lung damage, he has to the. Other places in apartment and took the maintenance personal 4 weeks to fix.! As well as other infections, such as athlete 's foot as well as other infections such... Professional as confirmed that its toxic black mold spores may cause previously nonsensitive individuals to become sensitive mold and... At the time litigation began, Ballard had become dissatisfied with the help of their attorney, must able!